Eating small fish
Yurts at Poncha Pass - Colorado Yurt Rentals and Sustainable Building Workshops - Photo of Chris in ground of Earthship

Written by Chris

May 18, 2014

t has been an interesting process studying marine biology over the years. Like Alice in Wonderland, the more I look into any given subject, the more infinite it feels. It is the nature of science I guess you could say. As I continue to tumble-down the rabbit hole, I’ve also come to believe the task falls on scientists to translate our scientific findings as we progress into easily understandable and readable pieces in addition to scientific publications. This needs to be done in the effort to get the information into the hands of the consumer/citizen so that they have the opportunity to make informed decisions. The idea of casting a daily vote for how we want our future to look, through the purchases we make, is fundamental. Thus, through communication, continual innovation, and action, the opportunity to take hold of our collective future becomes tangibly within reach.

Last summer, I worked on a master thesis regarding aquaculture and investigated many of the feeds we currently use to raise fish in hopes of finding and arguing for a more sustainable method. Like all major food production sectors, there are solutions for industry and actions that individuals can take. Since this is directed to you, the consumer or a title I have grown to appreciate more, the citizen, the question arises of what the individual can do regarding consumption of fish.

The quick and easy answer is to eat smaller herbivorous fish such as anchovies, sardines, and herring over the salmon and tuna that so many of us find so tasty. This in addition to a more vegetarian diet should be the direction we choose, but why? Industrial finfish aquaculture has historically been widely considered an inefficient way to grow fish that is neither sustainable nor ecologically friendly. Direct negative effects of finfish aquaculture can include habitat destruction, waste disposal, exotic specie introductions, spreading of pathogens, and depletion of food stocks for predator fish in the form of harvesting small pelagic fish for feed production.

These factors present significant hurdles to overcome; yet feed itself presents a very logical argument for why consumers should eat smaller fish. Historically, fishing vessels used fuel to go out and fish small species such as anchovies and sardines, naturally occurring mostly off the west coast of South America. That is brought back to a processing plant where it is turned into fish meal and fish oil, and then shipped to farmed salmon location in Europe and North America. The industry is in the middle of changing to include higher percentages of alternative food sources such as soy bean, maze, blood and meat byproduct along with a host of others. However, the strong reliance on wild catch pelagic fish and crop based fillers that require clearing land and devoting fresh water resources makes the process  an inadequate use of energy.

As techniques improve to allow more people eat smaller pelagic forage fish, there is the opportunity to feed a larger number of people when compared to the fish raised on fish meal and fish oil. This idea is based on the principle of energy conservation per trophic level, and although variable, is commonly accepted that 10% of energy is conserved with each higher trophic level. This means we could potentially feed 10 times the number of people on a small pelagic fish diet when compared to salmon or other higher trophic level species.

Tough to find better street food than the herring from a local market

Tough to find better street food than the herring from a local market

Additionally, since salmon and tuna are longer-lived species than anchovies and sardines, they will consume a greater biomass over their life spans resulting in higher accumulations of toxins such as mercury and dioxins. I wouldn’t go so far as to say all salmon or tuna rearing is done incorrectly, but when it comes to efficiencies and overall healthy fish, for the moment in the broad picture, sardines, herring, and anchovies are the way to go.

Related Articles

A Brave New World – The arrival of AI through flow of logic

A Brave New World – The arrival of AI through flow of logic

A Brave New World was written by Aldous Huxley and discusses just how a technological future might look like for earthlings. It sits atop a list of other noted books including 1984 (George Orwell) and The Foundation Series (Isaac Asimov) which eerily predict the...

Sphere of influence – the expanding/collapsible bubble

Sphere of influence – the expanding/collapsible bubble

Those who have known me for a while have heard occasionally about efforts to bring to market ocean wave driven pumps. Since 2009, I have been involved in the development of sustainable wave energy in some form or another. I still consult on the projects from time to...

The Ecosystem Engineer

The Ecosystem Engineer

Earlier this summer I went on a camping trip with my family. We drove up from New Mexico to Silverton Colorado and took the steam train down towards Durango. A ways down the canyon on the Animas River, we got off and spent two days camping along the river. It was...

Stay Up to Date by Following Us on Instagram

Follow Us

Be the first to see what’s new, workshop announcements, and yurt life on Poncha Pass.

Yurts at Poncha Pass - Colorado Yurt Rentals and Sustainable Building Workshops - Summer 2023 flyer earthship workshop
Yurts at Poncha Pass - Colorado Yurt Rentals and Sustainable Building Workshops - Spring 2023 Workshop group eating out


Come stay if you are looking for a peaceful and comfortable place to hang your hat while relaxing and adventuring around in nature. And after adventuring don’t forget to regenerate at a cellular level with our wood-burning sauna and cold plunge tub, immersed in good old fashioned nature therapy.